Two weeks ago, I proposed a 10-word Democratic agenda for financial freedom:
Treat cost disease, reduce the debt, and save Social Security.
Here is the Substack about treating cost disease in housing and healthcare. Here are the two about the politics and policy of reducing the debt. This week: saving Social Security.
Saving Social Security in the narrow sense means ensuring its solvency through 2100. It could be insolvent as soon as 2033. But Social Security is only one leg of the three-legged stool for retirement security. In the broad sense, saving Social Security also requires strengthening the other two legs of the stool. Those legs are personal savings, like your 401(k); and pensions or other defined-benefit products.
When all three legs are sturdy, Americans get a good mix of security and upside. Social Security is guaranteed but provides only a subsistence level of income. Pensions grow faster but have more risk. And then personal savings can capture outsize returns—but can also shrivel in a downturn.
To keep Social Security guaranteed, Congress needs to find $25 trillion over the next 75 years. Only one quarter of 18–49 year olds have confidence Congress can do that. Democrats should earn their trust by leading on sensible reforms for Social Security, which could include:
Increase its returns: allow Social Security to invest in the market through a sovereign wealth fund. This bipartisan proposal draws inspiration from the Thrift Savings Plan for federal employees, as well as other nations' retirement systems.
Index it to earnings: subject earnings above $400K to the Social Security payroll tax. Reduce benefits for higher-income retirees on a sliding scale.
Update it for longer lifespans: gradually increase the full retirement age. Establish exceptions for physically taxing jobs and waivers for hardship cases.
The second leg of the stool, pensions, needs even bigger reform. Down from 50% at the peak, today only 15% of private-sector workers have pensions. These defined benefits are sorely missed. Without them, a standard of living above Social Security is solely a function of personal investments. The pensions gap needs to be filled with defined benefits:
Long-term care insurance: 70% of Americans over 65 will require some type of long-term services and support. The market for long-term care (LTC) insurance should be strengthened so that more young Americans insure themselves. This may be complemented by allowing older individuals to proactively buy into Medicaid.
Annuities: increase uptake of guaranteed-income products through 401(k) plans.
More pensions: support collective bargaining for pensions in the private sector. New pension agreements may look like the Australian superannuation approach, which combine elements of 401(k)s, annuities, and pensions.
In addition to defined benefits through annuities and pensions, employers can also support the third leg of the stool: personal savings and investment. Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) give non-manager employees equity in the companies for which they work. These ESOPs should be allowed to vest in 401(k)s without counting towards annual contribution limits. The other side of this reform, which gives employees more stake in their current company, is to also make 401(k)s more portable, so that employees' savings seamlessly transfer when they do change jobs.
Retirement security is foundational to financial freedom. It is not only seniors who benefit. Social Security, for example, is the largest source of federal support for children. In an era of instability, Democrats must make saving Social Security, and strengthening the other two legs of the stool, a centerpiece of our economic platform.




These are good ideas, but I’d keep it simple to start - just remove the cap on wages subject to social security. That change alone would fix the funding problem. Once that’s corrected, other enhancements can be pursued.
I think the cap should be removed from Social Security contributions everyone should pay Social Security taxes. People with large incomes have been getting away with much less contributions, top taxable income is $176,100! What about all the rest who have an income above that! There should be taxes on total income!!